Wednesday, April 16, 2008

Mom tells kid no more WOW

Okay, a brief breakdown of this very typical family drama (apparently accidently recorded over game voice chat and posted by other players).

My gut reaction is painful as everyone is so out of tune with one another, the communication is derailed, and insight seems to be lacking on all fronts. These folks need help!

I've seen people comment that they young many is whiney, manipulative, immature, etc. I would say he has no self-regulatory ability whatsoever and doesn't seem to be in an environment which is helping him achieve any. He doesn't know what he's doing (though he is caught up in something that looks a lot like an addictive process with WoW) -and his parents doen't understand either. It's sad!!

I'd start by working to educate the parents. I'd want them to understand the following:

  • Their first mistake is assuming that a young guy this age is capable of self-monitoring and self-control. No one this age has a mature brain and their expectations for him are unrealistic.
  • Their son is playing a game with a structure they do not understand. He is highly caught up in the structured reinforcement system. This in-game structure is very powerful and it's expected that it would impact him this way. He has a need to play for multiple reasons that are based in neurobiology. He craves this experience.
  • It is for many people (even mature adults) impossible to play WoW without getting caught in the reinforcment structure and losing control
  • Many people experience dissociation and time loss while playing MMOs. Kids with ADHD often have "selective attention" and will concentrate so much on one activity that they ignore everything else around them. Whatever his internal experience is, it further impairs his judgment.
  • I believe he is indicating (some of it is garbled) that he "just got a group together" and is eager to complete a new and important task in the game. "How long it will take" is never something that can be predicted in advance. Again, they are asking him to do something that is impossible and they don't understand this. He naturally becomes frustrated (and responds with manipulation, which must have worked for him in the past).
  • By "bailing" on the group he will face a tremendous loss of esteem, particularly if he's the one who just organized it.
  • The other group members are listening to all this over the voice chat system. It's likely he's so upset he's not aware of this.
  • The parents say "You can finish it tomorrow night." Again, they don't understand that an MMO doesn't work this way. He's playing in real time, with real people, and he will not be able to "pick up where he left off."
  • I'd like to ask them who provided him with a computer, the game, and the broadband connection? Most likely they are paying his monthly subscription fee with their credit card. Essentially they have enabled the entire process and don't understand what they have done.
  • Trying to use "logic" at this time in this situation is completely counter productive. They're trying to communicate with the wrong part of his brain. Some more creative interventions need to be developed.
  • Mom and Dad don't seem to have any insight regarding what motivates their son to play. There are likely multiple reasons, some possibly having to do with real life (as opposed to virtual life) deficits, and if they don't figure this out they can't successfully solve the problem.

It's my hope that parents learn to play any game their child is playing and understand how to prevent these problems from developing in the first place. This situation is now so out of control that some sort of professional help is probably necessary. I'm frequently asked to consult regarding cases that have erupted into domestic violence. Hopefully they can find a therapist who understands the gaming process.

Final thought to Dad: NO, this is not "just a game."

3 comments:

Unknown said...

Agreed, these parents are obviously ignorant of why someone would play. After all, La Crosse is "just a game" as well isn't it? Yet I bet that Dad would argue with me if I said it is just "damaging" to him. I don't see too many people breaking limbs or noses playing video games. (unless they are incredibly bad at Wii or something)

Unknown said...

Agreed. These parents are obviously ignorant of why someone would play. After all lacrosse is "just a game" but I am willing to bet that he would argue with me if I told him it was "just damaging" to him. Which is more true with lacrosse, after all I don't see to many people breaking limbs playing video games (unless they are incredibly bad at Wii or something)

P. Shavaun Scott said...

Haha, okay I'm picturing someone really bad at Wii now...

Thanks for your comment Jeff :-)